my Good bad traders forum is now completly finished.

so any chance of getting a review or two?

its at: cdromforum.com

thanks

Hey Chopper,
Using the rating system here is what I would say...

Appearance Colors: Fair. I can't say I'm crazy about the yellow and orange. The yellow is a little to bright for a forum IMO.

Fonts: Fine/Normal. The top right navigation really add to the look. Very nice.

Graphics & Logos: Very good. I like the logo and it fits well with the site.

Layout & Backgrounds: Looks Good.

Functionality Navigation: All the topics seem to be in proper order. Since you have plenty of room, why not spell out Refs..
You also may want to change the minimum word length. A lot of people may try searching for PS1 or PS2 and it won't allow it. There was no HOME link after I did a search, so I had to use the link at the bottom.

Links: I didnt find any bad links...

Load Time: Good for a forum. Much faster than mine (I'm working on this!)

Bugs: None found.

Overall & Content Purpose of site: Seems to be a useful site so people don't get ripped off.

Does appearance and purpose of site match: Yep

Technical Typos, Wording, Grammar: You have a typo here:

"Recommended Trade Forums
Got a fvorite trading forum well post it in here and comments on them are welcome."

Favorite is spelled wrong above....

Overall, I would give it a 7. Good Job on the site.

Hope this helped you some.

Great. thanks for the review Tim.

ill get those little things fixed up.

And with the yellow i wasnt to sure about it at first. but once it was finished i quite liked it. Spose it depends on what colours you like.

anyways THANKS ALOT

Hey Chopper, here's my you know whats!

I think it looks good! I might have a shade defiecency (and can't spell), but I think the colors look good together. The only thing that doesn't seem to go with the color scheme is the blue guest please register box.

Is there a purpose to the white sidebar? If not, you might want to get rid of it and make the forum across the entire page.

Load time was good. I didn't find any broken links and navigation was good. There is a link at bottom, Contact Us and Trade Watcher. Is the Trade Watcher link necessary? It only reloads page.

Overall, it seems like the place to go for traders. I'm gonna have to check some of that out with all these CD's we got.... I didn't see any rules listed. Side note: How do you keep arguements or name-calling down?

As for the technicalities, like spelling and such, well....the Confirming Rippers doesn't need the period.....refs could be spelled out on Refs. check point and it doesn't need the period.....and start sentence with caps under Confirmed Rippers for consistency....and spelling of favorite under Recommended Buy....

Ok, so I give it a high 7. Maybe an 8 without that white sidebar and the technical stuff listed above.

Good job Chopper! It's looks like a place to be for traders.

Dave