This Rating System
can be used as a guide for rating other member's sites.
Suggested rating system for site reviews:
Virtually flawless - among the best on the web!
A "must-visit" site!
Exceeds all expectations!
Excellent website - all expectations met.
Great - considerable effort put into website.
Very good - meets most expectations.
Good - better than most on the web
Fair - improvements needed but not too bad.
Below average. -- noticeable lapses in design, functionality, or content
Needs improvement -- major lapses in design, functionality, or content
Needs much improvement -- major lapses in design, functionality, and wording
Should consider reworking of almost all of the website.
Should consider total redesign
This doesn't have to be used, but can be a starting place. It is suggested never using 1 - 3, but most of those will be submitted here. It's not a good system for comparing sites (like the ol' apples and oranges thing), since sites have different themes and purposes; each site should be rated on it's own merits.
Suggested Rating Criteria:
- Appearance Colors, Fonts, Graphics, Logos, Layout, Backgrounds
- Functionality Navigation, Links, Load Time, Bugs
- Overall & Content Purpose of site, and Does appearance and purpose of site match
- Technical Typos, Wording, Grammar
If changes are made to your site after the initial site review, you may bump your thread so it can be reviewed again.
If you want a review of your site, please be sure to review 3 other WT member sites before posting your site for review. Make sure you read the rules for this forum.
School Grade Equivalents Chart:
= A+ 98%
= A 95%
= A- 91%
= B+ 88%
= B 85%
= B- 81%
= C+ 78%
= C 75%
= C- 71%
= D 65%
= F 51%
Please note: You can get a 7.5, and that would equate to 90%. A 5.5 would be around 84%. Etc.
[Shey] Old rules has been moved to Private-talk